In this proposal, key issues will be identified, and an unexplored
solution presented. This blue sidebar will present relevant quotes,
definitions, statistics, and will, in time, be fully linked to sources.
Some Key Notes From:
Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development 2002 Report - Chapter 3
Some Key Notes From:
Mines Ministers' Conference 2002 Winnipeg, Manitoba Action Plan 2001: Status Reports The report made several conclusions and recommendations with respect to voluntary abatement, remediation or reclamation of abandoned mines, which are briefly summarized below: (p.20)
Ministers agreed with stakeholder and industry representatives that continued emphasis on the development, in the short term, of strategies related to rehabilitation of orphaned and abandoned mine sites adapted to the needs of each jurisdictions is a priority. (p.2) Concentrate - The economically valuable minerals separated from the gangue. Gangue - The rock surrounding a mineral or precious gem in its natural state. Anomaly - An area where metals or minerals exist in concentrations that are much higher than normal. Trends There has been an increase in skill requirements across all sectors of the economy. Business and government are placing considerable emphasis on the need for continuous work-force training and lifelong learning. As Canada's training system expands to meet the needs of these learners, there will be new opportunities for Canadian suppliers of education and training services. Canada's education & training industry is well positioned to compete in the international marketplace. Diverse players...
The global corporate and government training market is valued at US $98B. (Merrill Lynch. Book of Knowledge, 1999). IT Training, a sub sector of the corporate market, is worth US $19B. (Merrill Lynch). In 2000, Canada's educational service industries (including public education) was valued at $41B., or 5.2% of GDP. Abandoned mine - A mine site that has not been properly cleaned up and closed down and whose ownership has reverted to the federal or provincial government because the owner has gone out of business. Acid rock drainage (ARD) - The results from a reaction of sulphur-containing minerals exposed to air and water, producing a toxic acidic run-off that damages ecosystems. ARD is mainly associated with the mining of coal, copper, & other base or precious metals.
Some Key Notes From:
A damning report released on Canada's worst toxic sites and abandoned mines reveals what most suspected: a massive cleanup is desperately needed and Ottawa is dragging its heels.
CTV.ca - Ottawa slammed over toxic sites, closed mines October 22, 2002 Johanne Gelinas, the Federal Commissioner of the Environment, says in her six-volume report that the government has bungled the clean-up of the thousands of sites across the country, and needs to spend billions of dollars to deal with the mess. The report says there are more than 3,600 contaminated sites on federal land that Ottawa must deal with and another 1,500 sites where contamination is suspected. They include harbours, ports, military bases, government laboratories and abandoned mines. Cyanide - A poisonous substance that is widely used in mining and other industrial processes. The most common form of cyanide is hydrocyanic acid (HCN), which is used in recovering ore, in electroplating and for fumigation. Other forms are sodium cyanide, potassium cyanide and calcium cyanide. All are found in the form of a salt, but can be dissolved in water to form a liquid or a gas. Cyanide is a highly toxic substance when ingested or inhaled. Arsenic trioxide - A white, odourless, tasteless powder (also known as crude arsenic), which is a poisonous and cancer-causing chemical. Tailings - What is left over from mining; the rock where gold, copper, silver and other minerals are found is ground up into fine particles so the valuable material can be taken out and refined. Most of the ore, sometimes as high as 97% from mining and refining operations, end up as tailings. It usually amounts to hundreds of thousands of tonnes a year at a mine site.
Some Key Notes From:
PITTSBURGH (AP) - Rarely does anyone advertise to buy 400 tons of cow manure, but that's what Bob Du Breucq did to get enough fertilizer for a water treatment project at a mine in central Pennsylvania.
cnews.canoe.ca - Cow manure used to treat mine drainage January 6, 2003 As vice president of Tanoma Mining Co., which ceased operating in 2000, Du Breucq had the task of putting together a reclamation project to make sure contaminated mine water doesn't pollute nearby waterways. He settled on building a high-calcium settling pond with limestone and cow manure that will reduce the acidity of water seeping out of the mine --a process that mine reclamation experts say is safe for the environment and inexpensive. Besides using cow manure, Skousen said other fertilizers such as sawdust; hay and mushroom compost can be just as effective. Ore - A natural aggregate of one or more minerals that can be mined and profitably sold under current conditions, or from which one or more minerals can be profitably extracted. Tailings slurry - Created when the fine tailings are mixed with water, creating a thin, watery mixture. The slurry is often contaminated with material used in the refining process, including cyanide. Heap Leaching - Cyanide heap leaching is a process used with very low-grade ore. Rather than use expensive mechanical processes, tonnes of ground-up rock are simply piled into giant heaps, usually contained in "leach pads" lined with a plastic membrane. Then the ore is sprayed with cyanide and water to "leach" out the tiny bits of gold. It's the cheapest way to get what's left out of the ground. But it's also a tough process to manage.
Some Key Notes From:
What inventories of abandoned mines have been completed in your province / territory?
Orphaned/Abandoned Mines Workshop - June 2001 Proceedings W. O. MACKASEY WOM GEOLOGICAL ASSOCIATES INC. Only five provinces had what I would call systematic abandoned mines inventories. The remainder had lists or files in varying stages of completion and organization. The inventory for the Territories included only sites with no legally responsible party in operation. The Ontario inventory was based on the Ontario Geological Survey Mineral Deposit Inventory and appears to be the most complete. There is no consistency in the type of agency in charge of the inventory - it varies from Natural Resources, Mines, Environment, Energy … to Indian and Northern Affairs. How many abandoned mine sites have been identified and are on file? Approximately 10,000 sites are on record in Canada. In my opinion, however, until systematic surveys are completed we will never know the exact number. We must look at the records of old mining exploration programs, not just past producers. We are talking here about the possibility of thousands, not tens of thousands. It is essential that all sites, irrespective of ownership, be included. Of the abandoned mine sites identified, what percentage has been verified by field inspections? The answer to this question really depends on what's included in the original survey. If the files show ten sites and all of them have been inspected, then the answer is 100%. However, did anyone look through the Mineral Deposit Inventory files? Is there a Mineral Deposit Inventory file? There are no standards across Canada on what should be included. I suspect that less than 30% of what really needs to be field inspected has been done. How many sites were found to have physical / chemical stability problems? What percentage has undergone remedial work? The answer to this question is not good. Although 10's of millions of dollars (my estimate) have been spent on reclamation - there is no consistency across Canada in either record keeping, or amount of work done. Some provinces/territories have made an effort; others appear to have done nothing. Sulphuric Acid (H2SO4) - Acid commonly used in industry for the refining of metals, solvent extraction of uranium and in the manufacture of chemicals and fertiliser. Sulphur Dioxide (SO2) - A gas that contributes to climate effects, acidification and other air quality problems. Acidic Water - Referring to water with a pH below 7 but generally referring to pH values of 4 and below. Any water solution where the concentration of hydrogen ions (H+) is greater than the concentration of hydroxide ions (OH-).
A Key Note From:
DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYTICAL METHODS:
The ability to assess environmental problems, compare them, and select strategies to reduce them all depend on
the availability of relevant data and analytical tools. Sound data to evaluate risks and establish priorities did not
--- and in many cases still do not --- exist in the Animas. In addition to the lack of data, inadequate methods for
prioritization impeded the project on the Animas. As long as there are large gaps in key data sets, efforts to
evaluate risk and establish priorities in a consistent, rigorous manner necessarily will be incomplete and the
results of remediation will be difficult to interpret.
Prioritization of Abandoned Mines in the Animas Watershed, Colorado Carol Cox Russell EPA - US Government
A Key Note From:
Reductive Precipitation Technology:
Dr. Larry Twidwell, President of Montana Environment and
Metallurgical Engineering Professor at Montana Tech, is the developer of the Reductive
Precipitation Process. MSE licenses the technology. Reductive Precipitation is a proven
technology that effectively removes arsenic and other heavy metals by forming insoluble salts.
Pilot-scale studies have proven that the Reductive Precipitation effectively reduces arsenic and
antimony concentrations to less than the EPA drinking water standards of 10 parts per billion
(ppb) for arsenic and 6 ppb for antimony. MSE has been successfully marketing this technology.
The technology was implemented at a high profile superfund site in Emeryville, California to
remove arsenic from groundwater. MSE designed, installed, and commissioned the full-scale
plant. The Reductive Precipitation process has been operating successfully since March 1999.
The Reductive Precipitation process has reliably operated since March of 1999. Current
potential customers interested in implementation of this process are Rhone-Poulenc Basic
Chemicals Company; Salt Lake City Supply Water facilities; and Camp, Dresser and McKee.
Mine Waste Technology Program Success Stories MSE Technology Applications, Inc (US Government) Concentrate - is the product of ore treatment and contains metal at a higher concentration than the source ore. In metallurgical processes for the production of nickel and copper, concentrate is smelted to produce a metallic compound suitable for further refining. Neutral drainage - A term generally referring to neutral Ferich water and subsequent precipitates. Acidic drainage is a common result from the exposure of sulphur containing coal and sulphide-bearing rocks. Acidic drainage is (generally) characterized by yellow, ferric hydroxide precipitates that drop out downstream from discharge points. However, similar precipitates also form naturally in places where Fe-bearing, anoxic (ground) waters discharge into streams. In these circum-neutral settings, the precipitates have red and red-orange hues. Toxicity - Measure how harmful a substance is.
A Key Note From:
This report is a wake-up call.
No single dedicated funding source is available to state and
federal agencies to tackle the human health and environmental problems of abandoned
mines. Left unattended, relatively small problems grow worse. Squabbles over royalties
have long delayed congressional action forcing state governors, local communities and
private organizations to either turn a blind eye to the problem or cobble together funding
from disparate sources.
Settled, Mined & Left Behind A Report Produced by Trout Unlimited’s Public Lands Initiative (US Organization)
A Key Note From:
Funding cutbacks
have worsened teacher student ratios – there are three percent
fewer FTE faculty in Canada’s universities than there were a decade ago,
while the FTE number of students has grown by more than 26 percent over the same period.
Canadian Post-Secondary Education at a Crossroads Presentation by: James L. Turk Executive Director Canadian Association of University Teachers November 27, 2005 pH - It is based on a scale from 0 to 14. On this scale, 0 is the most acidic value, and 14 is the most alkaline value. Seven would be neutral. A change of 1 pH unit represents a 10-fold change in acidity or alkalinity. A range from 6.5 to 8.2 is optimal for most organisms. Dissolved minerals from rocks and soil contribute to pH, but reaction of dissolved carbon dioxide with water is a major determinant. Sources of abnormal acidic readings include acid mine drainage, industrial effluent, acid rain, sewage lagoons, and livestock containment areas. Sources of alkaline conditions include concrete plants, water treatment plants, and raw sewage Specific Conductance - The ability of water to conduct an electrical current, which is the measure of the quantity of ions in the water (typically measured in micromhos). It is determined by the presence of inorganic dissolved solids, such as salts. Measurements outside the normal range for a stream (5 to 150) may indicate the presence of a contaminant. These testing parameters serve as a check to make sure pollutants are not being overlooked that are not part of the regular sampling routine. [distilled water = 0.5 - 3.0 / healthy lakes 15 - 50 / typical rivers 5 to 150 / industrial effluent 10,000] Microbial Technologies collaborated in the development of an innovative system to treat the acid rock drainage (ARD) at the Island Copper Mine. Our solution was to engineer a stable, two-layer (meromictic) lake that acts as a passive treatment system in the 400-m deep open pit. A physico-chemical model predicted that flooding the mine pit with seawater, then capping it with a layer of freshwater would produce a lake that will remain stable for at least 350 years ... The pit was partly flooded with seawater in July 1996, then allowed fill with rainfall (freshwater). The bottom water layer became anoxic by 1998, and SRB became established shortly thereafter. Early indications are that metal concentrations in the lake bottom are beginning to decrease. Thus, the results to date are consistent with our modeling predictions, and give us confidence that this innovative treatment system will perform as expected.
A Key Note From:
It has been determined that there are approximately 5,600 known
abandoned mine sites in Ontario, containing about 16,500 individual features.
These sites range in magnitude from single, shallow mine shafts and deep
trenches or pits, to mines that have produced millions of tons of ore.
Ontario Mines and Minerals Division Abandoned Mines/Mine Hazards Linked June 29, 2007 Estimates have been made that it will cost approximately $500 million to rehabilitate all of the abandoned mine sites in Ontario. Of these, it has been further estimated that it will cost about $200 million to rehabilitate the 30% to 40% of these sites that have reverted to the Crown.
A Key Note From:
Some of the practices that led to today's problems were due to
ignorance or negligence. But we should bear in mind that the practices that
caused the contamination were often carried out in a much different social,
legal and scientific context. These practices would not be tolerated today,
but in the past they were often common practice and they often met the standard
of the day.
Improving Federal Stewardship of Contaminated Sites Speaking Notes for the Honourable Stéphane Dion, P.C., M.P. Minister of the Environment at Giant Mine, Yellowknife, NWT August 2, 2005 Linked June 29, 2007 We have inherited the problem, and we must solve it. Today, our knowledge has increased, our environmental standards are higher and we all know that the contamination cannot be left to fester and continue to damage our ecosystems. We know what needs to be done: prevent new contamination and clean up the mess inherited from the past. |
Concept and Funding ProposalWhat is it? Who built it? Did it work? - Mount Washington (2001)(click image to view more images) Forward
In Canada we have a problem. We have abandoned mine-sites polluting the environment and funds cannot be found for the remediation. The cost of cleanup is projected to exceed one billion dollars but no one really knows for sure. The private sector, in most cases, is willing to help but far too scared to be involved. Liability is always an issue due to future lawsuits if current work does not result in complete remediation. Finding a contractor even willing to enter a site can be difficult. Numerous governments, and private groups, have attempted, over the years, to solve individual site problems but there is no cohesive lasting plan in the works to date.
A Solution
The geo-Logical method is grounded in a tried and true educational tool, known by many names, but finding its roots in antiquity: apprenticeship training, hands-on training, and today, the word 'practicum.' The trend in education, and demanded by industry, is to ready students for the work place with a blend of classroom instruction and practical hands-on, in field, training. Well established for the accounting, legal, medical, and blue collar trades; practicum components are now part of all fisheries, forestry, and engineering courses. Environmental geology and engineering, on the other hand, except for short field trips and summer employment, offer little opportunity to get dirty and callused hands.
Hurdles
All venture launches have hoops and hurdles to master and geo-Logical is far from exempt. The temptation to rush launching of the service must be restrained. While the need is obvious from both an environmental point of view, and an educational vantage point, the infrastructure must be in place and proven prior to launch. The technologies exist but they are still new and bugs can crush confidence. geo-Logical, to be successful, must not only ensure remediation of abandoned mine-sites, but it must deliver dependable education that students can rely upon. Further, student's safety will be an issue, due to the remote nature of mine-sites, and while technology cannot prevent accidents, it can reduce response time to provide aide.
Industry Opportunity
The world is going 'green' and the push for creative alternate energy systems is well underway. The coupling of education to the cleanup of remote mine-sites will fuel the need for dependable energy and anything other than use of 'clean-energy' is ruled out to avoid contributing to an already compromised ecosystem. All camps also produce waste and this sector, like the energy sector, demands field proven systems. geo-Logical not only provides a testing facility but an online marketing sales tool as a side effect of its operation.
The Two-Year Test Site
Numerous sites have been examined with the forerunner the Sherridon Mine in Northern Manitoba.
The mine-site is considered one of Canada's worst and requires ongoing security due to its location
encompassing the town of Sherridon. The mine has been closed for nearly half a century and Mother Nature
has been unable to hide the scars --still clearly visible from
aerial photos. The proximity to Kississing Lake,
a premier sport fishing lake, creates great concern to locals and all levels of government.
Further, the site is accessible by road, a great benefit for a test-site, and possesses such a
broad range of problems that anything accomplished toward remediation will be an achievement.
And What If It Does Not Work Out?
geo-Logical must be started with the attitude that in the end continuation may not be deemed viable.
It is through data collection that a residual asset is guaranteed regardless of the outcome.
The benefit to the local community and government, after two years of data collection,
cannot be under stated. Most sites, along with Sherridon, do not have 24/7 monitoring for an
extended period of time through all seasons and all manner of weather conditions.
Corporation Statusgeo-Logical's tax status will be determined by the Board of Directors, however, initially, geo-Logical will function as a not-for-profit corporation. What Will It All Cost? Who Will Pay?
The actual costs beyond the two-year test site cannot be determined at this time as each site will be unique and have its own administration costs due to location and severity of contamination. As for 'who will pay' for actual costs beyond the two year test site, similarly, there are far too many variables to be addressed such as: how much can universities contribute out of existing budget line items; what costs beyond tuition, if any, are passed on to the student; are there responsible parties available and able to pay for remediation; what funds are government departments currently paying for security; and so on.
The estimate purposely omits typical costs such as food, accommodation, field equipment, technical equipment and services, etc. These items will be secured by donation, loan, barter (seat on board), black-mail (get on now or wait for the next bus), and/or are covered by the salary portion of the estimate. What Can Government Do?Provide initial funding, provide initial funding … loan monitoring devices, research services, technical expertise, assist with site selection, and provide initial funding. What Can The Private Sector Do?Provide initial funding and do much the same as government with a specific focus on technical expertise and provision of services. What Can The Education Sector Do?Funds are Ok too but enthusiasm and technical expertise is the most valuable desired asset. Monetary Returngeo-Logical will deal with a billion dollar problem, economically, and responsible parties should pay for services rendered but the final decision will rest with the Board of Directors. Key Employees
[President]
Time Tablegeo-Logical should be ready to pick a site anytime and 'move on' will be determined by snow levels and accessibility. Plan 2007
Tour abandoned, orphaned and reclaimed mine sites in northern BC, Yukon, as well as southern Alaska.
An opportunity exists during summer 2007 to take the venture beyond the conceptual stage. Time permits
an investment of two to three months devoted to data collection and site selection. During this period
the website would be redesigned to accommodate the large amounts of data and associated images.
Conclusion
This is a preliminary proposal and additional information can and will be provided upon request. There are always unanswered questions such as: who owns the land after remediation; who should own the land; should geo-Logical be for profit or not; what are the tax advantages either way; what is it worth to the government to remove a thorn from its side; and so on? Foreseeing these questions is the driving force behind the creation of a Board of Directors to steer geo-Logical in the right direction. Further, the exact disposition of ownership of geo-Logical will rest with the board as well. As stated previously, this is a billion-dollar problem and billion-dollar problems create billion-dollar opportunity. geo-Logical is a long-term solution to a legacy left by builders of this nation. The resource industry has contributed much to what Canada is today and through geo-Logical the legacy can continue to do so.
Read Till Your Eyes Pop Out
- Initiatives at Natural Resources Canada to Deal with Orphan and Abandoned Mines. NRCan ->Tremblay, GA & Hogan, CM, 2006. - Capacity Building For A National Inventory of Orphaned/Abandoned Mines In Canada. NOAMI ->Cal Data Ltd. 2005. - Potential Funding Approaches for Orphaned/Abandoned Mines in Canada. NOAMI -> Castrilli, J. 2003. - Rehabilitating Abandoned Mines in Canada: A Toolkit of Funding Options. NOAMI -> Cowan W. Mackasey W. 200610. - Orphaned and Abandoned Mines: A Workshop to Explore Best Practices. NOAMI -> Stratoss Inc. 200612. - Assessing Liabilities and Funding Options. NOAMI -> Stratos Inc. 200511. - Programs to Enhance and Sustain Safety and the Quality of the Environment In and Around Orphaned and Abandoned Mine Sites. NRCan -> CANMET - Best Practices in Community Involvement: Planning For and Rehabilitating Abandoned Mines in Canada. NOAMI -> brochure - Prioritization of Abandoned Mines in the Animas Watershed, Southwestern Colorado. EPA -> Russell C. - Mine Waste Technology Program: 2005 Annual Report. EPA/DOE -> Montana Tech. 2005. - Mine Waste Technology Program: Success Stories. EPA/DOE -> MSE Tech. - Abandoned Mine Land Program Policy Handbook Bureau of Land Management -> 20070320. pub # H-3720-1 - Settled, Mined & Left Behind Trout Unlimited -> Schnitzer R. & R. Roberts. 2004. - Restoring the Wealth of the Mountains: Cleaning up Appalachia's Abandoned Mines Trout Unlimited -> Zink T., A. Wolfe & K. Curley. 2005. - Abandoned Mines: Problems, Issues, and Policy Challenges for Decision Makers. Santiago, Chile -> 20010618. - Mining for Closure: Policies and Guidelines for Sustainable Mining Practice and Closure of Mines. ENVSEC -> Peck, P. 2005. - Mining for the Future. Appendix C: Abandoned Mines Working Paper. MMSD -> IIED. 2002. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Last Modified: August 14, 2007 Download printable copy (2007) of this proposal --> geo-logical.pdf (does not contain all website content and it is big!) |